Thanksgiving Side Dishes: 15 Classics (and a Few New Favorites)
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Photo: Famartin, via Wikimedia Commons
Ask ten Americans what makes Thanksgiving dinner, and you will get ten different answers — but not one of them will say the turkey. It is always the sides. The turkey is the centerpiece, sure. It is also the thing people politely take a little of, and then go back for the mashed potatoes.
So here is the short answer, up front: the perfect Thanksgiving table needs mashed potatoes, stuffing, gravy, cranberry sauce, and one green vegetable. Everything after that is a bonus. This list gives you all fifteen dishes worth considering: twelve classics, plus three newer favorites that have quietly become the dishes people ask about. Pick five or six, cook them well, and nobody will remember whether the turkey was perfect.
One dish on this list was not a family recipe at all. It was invented in a test kitchen in 1955 by a home economist who was just trying to sell soup — and it now shows up on roughly 20 million Thanksgiving tables a year. I will tell you which one when we get there.
The 15 at a Glance
| Dish | Why it earns its spot | Make ahead? |
|---|---|---|
| Buttery mashed potatoes | The dish everyone goes back for | Yes, reheat with butter and milk |
| Classic bread stuffing | The flavor of Thanksgiving itself | Assemble a day ahead |
| Turkey gravy | Ties the whole plate together | Yes, up to 3 days |
| Cranberry sauce | The only tart, bright thing on the plate | Yes, up to a week |
| Green bean casserole | Crunchy, creamy, nostalgic | Assemble a day ahead |
| Sweet potato casserole | Sweet, soft, endlessly argued over | Yes, bake day-of |
| Baked mac and cheese | The kid favorite adults secretly love | Assemble a day ahead |
| Soft dinner rolls | For mopping up gravy | Bake day-of |
| Roasted Brussels sprouts | Crispy, salty, caramelized edges | Roast day-of |
| Cornbread | Southern staple, stuffing's cousin | Bake a day ahead |
| Roasted butternut squash | Sweet, golden, oven-friendly | Roast day-of |
| Creamed corn | Rich, spoonable comfort | Yes, reheat gently |
| Miso-glazed carrots (new) | Sweet, salty, and different | Glaze day-of |
| Shaved Brussels sprout and apple salad (new) | The fresh, crunchy counterpoint | Dress at serving |
| Wild rice pilaf with mushrooms (new) | Hearty, savory, gluten-free friendly | Yes, reheats well |
What Are the Most Popular Thanksgiving Side Dishes?
If you asked a room full of Americans to name the sides they cannot imagine Thanksgiving without, the same five would come up every time: mashed potatoes, stuffing, gravy, cranberry sauce, and green bean casserole. Each one does a job nothing else on the plate does — soft and rich, savory and herby, a rescue for dry turkey, something sharp and bright, and crunch. Beyond that core five, the next tier is family tradition — and your family's version is the one that matters.
How Many Side Dishes Do You Need for Thanksgiving?
For four to six people, four sides are plenty: mashed potatoes, stuffing, cranberry sauce, and one vegetable. For eight to twelve, aim for five or six — add gravy, a second vegetable, and rolls. Past twelve guests, seven or eight sides make sense, because people want choice and you want leftovers worth eating. The mistake is not cooking too few sides. It is cooking too many of the same kind: three creamy, beige, buttery dishes and nothing bright or crunchy is a tired plate. Pick one starchy comfort dish, one green vegetable, one sweet dish, one tart or fresh dish, and one bread. If the budget is part of the planning too, our guide to hosting Thanksgiving on a budget shows where the real savings hide.
The Classics
1. Buttery Mashed Potatoes. The single most important side on the table. Use russet or Yukon Gold potatoes, salt the water like pasta water, and warm the butter and milk before you add them — cold dairy on hot potatoes makes gluey potatoes; warm dairy makes clouds. Mash by hand, stop the second they look smooth. Five pounds serves about eight — and you will wish you had made six.
2. Classic Bread Stuffing. Dried bread cubes, onion, celery, sage, thyme, butter, and stock, baked until the top is crisp and the middle is soft. Dry your bread a day ahead — stale bread soaks up stock without falling apart. If you cook it inside the bird, it must reach 165°F all the way through. Baking it separately is easier and safer — and you get more of the crispy top everyone fights over.
3. Turkey Gravy. Gravy is not really a side dish. It is the thing that rescues everything else on the plate, including turkey that came out a little dry. The recipe is a ratio: equal parts fat and flour, cooked for a minute, then warm drippings and stock whisked in slowly until it thickens. If yours goes wrong — lumpy, too thin, too salty — it can almost always be fixed. We wrote a whole guide to it: how to make Thanksgiving gravy from scratch (and fix it when it goes wrong).
4. Cranberry Sauce. Fifteen minutes and one pan: a bag of cranberries, sugar, water, and orange zest, simmered until the berries pop and the sauce thickens. It will look thin in the pan and set up as it cools — do not keep cooking it. Make it up to a week ahead; it only gets better in the fridge. And the honest take on the canned kind: plenty of families love the ridged cylinder from the can, so put out both.
5. Green Bean Casserole. Here is the payoff to that story from the top. Green bean casserole was invented in 1955 by Dorcas Reilly, a home economist at the Campbell's test kitchen in Camden, New Jersey. The Associated Press had asked for a quick vegetable side made from ingredients most households already kept on hand, and Reilly came back with six: green beans, cream of mushroom soup, milk, soy sauce, black pepper, and fried onions. First called the Green Bean Bake, Campbell's now estimates it is served at about 20 million Thanksgiving dinners a year. Seventy years on, the recipe on the soup can is barely changed — and the fried onions are still the best part.
6. Sweet Potato Casserole. Sweet potatoes mashed with butter, brown sugar, and a little cinnamon, topped with toasted marshmallows or a brown sugar and pecan crumble. Families split hard on the topping — marshmallow people and pecan people rarely convert — so feed both camps with two small dishes instead of one big one. Assemble a day ahead, bake while the turkey rests. A squeeze of orange juice keeps the mash from tasting one-note sweet.
The Ones That Round Out the Table
7. Baked Mac and Cheese. It used to be a Southern tradition at Thanksgiving; now it is everywhere. It is the dish children actually eat, and adults eat it too when nobody is watching. Bake it with a sharp cheddar sauce and a buttered breadcrumb top. Assemble the day before, bake while the turkey rests.
8. Soft Dinner Rolls. Rolls do two jobs: they soak up gravy, and they give people something to eat while dinner is five minutes away for the third time. Store-bought frozen rolls baked fresh are completely fine — brush them with melted butter the second they come out of the oven and nobody will ask questions. From scratch, make the dough the night before and let it rise in the fridge.
9. Roasted Brussels Sprouts. Cut them in half, toss with oil and salt, and roast cut-side down at 425°F until the flat sides are deeply browned. That caramelized edge is the whole dish — boiled Brussels sprouts are the reason the vegetable has a bad reputation, and roasted ones are the reason it does not deserve it anymore. Finish with lemon zest or balsamic.
10. Cornbread. Cornbread belongs on the table in its own right, not just as stuffing's raw material. Bake it in a cast-iron skillet with a hot, buttered pan so the edges go crisp, and serve it warm with honey butter. In the South it is often the base of the dressing itself. Either way, it is the fastest bread on this list.
11. Roasted Butternut Squash. Cubes of butternut squash roasted with olive oil, salt, and a little maple syrup until the edges catch and caramelize. It is sweet without being dessert, golden on the plate, and it roasts at the same temperature as almost everything else — which matters when the oven is the busiest place in the house. Toss with toasted pecans and sage at the end.
12. Creamed Corn. Corn kernels simmered in butter, cream, and a pinch of sugar until spoonable and rich. It is the quiet dish on the table — nobody talks about it beforehand, and the bowl is always empty. Frozen corn works just as well as fresh. Keep the heat low and stir often — scorched cream is a smell you cannot undo.
A Few New Favorites Worth Trying
13. Miso-Glazed Carrots. Roast whole carrots until tender, then brush them with a glaze of white miso, honey, and a little rice vinegar, and roast five minutes more. The miso gives them a salty, savory depth plain glazed carrots never had. One sheet pan, almost no attention.
14. Shaved Brussels Sprout and Apple Salad. After twelve rich dishes, the table needs one thing that is fresh and crunchy. Shave raw Brussels sprouts thin, toss with matchstick apples, toasted pecans, shaved Parmesan, and a lemon and olive oil dressing. Dress it right before serving so it stays crisp. It is the dish people reach for between bites of everything else.
15. Wild Rice Pilaf with Mushrooms. Wild rice cooked in stock with sautéed mushrooms, onion, celery, and herbs, finished with toasted walnuts and dried cranberries. It is hearty, savory, naturally gluten-free, and it reheats better than almost anything on this list — the rare side that tastes just as good on Friday, piled onto a leftover turkey sandwich.
Can You Make Thanksgiving Side Dishes Ahead of Time?
Yes — most of them, and you should. Cranberry sauce keeps a week in the fridge. Gravy keeps three days. Stuffing and mac and cheese can be assembled a day ahead and baked on the day. Mashed potatoes can be made ahead and reheated gently with a splash of milk and a knob of butter, though they are at their best made fresh. The dishes that cannot wait are the roasted vegetables: Brussels sprouts, squash, and carrots lose their crisp edges within an hour, so roast them while the turkey rests — about 20 to 30 minutes of free oven time.
How Do You Keep Thanksgiving Side Dishes Warm?
The oven at 200°F, covered loosely with foil, and a slow cooker for the things that like it moist. Mashed potatoes and creamed corn hold beautifully in a slow cooker on warm with extra butter on top. Casseroles can sit covered in a low oven. Rolls stay warm wrapped in a clean towel inside a basket. And the real secret is staggering: serve the dishes that go cold fast first, and let the casseroles wait. A dish that is slightly cooler than ideal is still dinner. A frantic host is a worse problem than lukewarm green beans.
What Side Dishes Go With Turkey Besides Stuffing?
If stuffing is not your family's thing, the best partners for turkey are mashed potatoes with gravy, roasted Brussels sprouts, cranberry sauce, and dinner rolls. That is a complete plate: soft, green, tart, and bread. Add the wild rice pilaf if you want something hearty in stuffing's place, and the shaved Brussels sprout salad if you want something fresh.
Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26 this year, and the sides are the part of dinner people talk about on the drive home. Pick five or six from this list — the classics your family expects, plus one new favorite to surprise them — and cook them well. And when dinner is over, the leftovers start their second life: here is how to store leftover turkey safely and how long it really lasts, so none of those good sides go to waste.
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Comments
Post a Comment